Wind Turbine Tower Man Door and Ventilation Opening Buckling in Ansys: GMNIA after Gantes et al. (2024)

€129,00
Optional extras

Need a full custom project? See the options below.

€129,00
Optional extras

Need a full custom project? See the options below.

17 people watching this product now!

Material Includes

  • Ansys Workbench project (.wbpz) with all four cases
  • APDL input files per case: mesh, linear buckling, imperfection, GMNIA, extraction
  • One-click Python run script
  • Results report (PDF): every result side by side with the paper
  • README

Audience

  • Wind-energy and tower engineers designing door and vent reinforcement
  • FEA engineers learning LBA + GMNIA shell buckling in Ansys
  • MSc and PhD students in shell buckling and steel structures

What You Will Learn?

  • Rebuild the man door and ventilation opening study of Gantes et al. (2024) in Ansys with four shell models.
  • Run a linear buckling analysis and turn its modes into initial imperfections.
  • Trace the equilibrium path past the peak load with a GMNIA and arc-length control.
  • Model openings, a door plate and a stiffening frame on a cylindrical shell with SHELL181.
  • Apply the paper design actions at a rigid top node and read the load factor against top displacement.
  • Run every case in one click with the included Python script and compare with the paper.

About Course

How much buckling strength does a man door take out of a tubular steel wind turbine tower, and how much does a door plate and frame give back? This Ansys package reproduces the journal paper Gantes, Vernardos, Koulatsou and Gül, “Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis of Tubular Steel Wind Turbine Towers near Man Door and Ventilation Openings to Optimize Design against Buckling”, Vibration 2024, 7, 212–228 (doi: 10.3390/vibration7010012) with a shell model of the lowest 11 m of the tower: linear buckling (LBA), buckling-mode imperfections and a GMNIA with arc-length control that follows each tower past its peak load. You get the Ansys Workbench project (.wbpz), the APDL input files for all four cases and a one-click Python run script that builds and solves every case automatically.

Wind turbine tower buckling at a man door in Ansys: von Mises contour and load factor vs displacement against the paper
Bare man door after the peak load (MAPDL von Mises contour, left) and the load factor against top displacement for the three man-door cases, paper (dashed) vs Ansys (right).

Watch: wind turbine tower man door buckling in Ansys

The paper behind the model

Gantes and co-authors look at the bottom section of a tubular steel wind turbine tower, where the man door and ventilation openings cut through the shell exactly where the bending moment is largest. With nonlinear finite element analysis that includes geometric and material nonlinearity and initial imperfections, they compare an intact shell with a bare door, doors reinforced with thicker plates and a stiffening frame, and ventilation openings with different wind directions, and use the equilibrium paths to rank the reinforcement options against buckling. (Summary in our own words; see the paper for the full abstract.)

Model at a glance

ItemThis package
StructureLowest 11 m of a tubular S355 steel tower, radius 2150 mm, shell cans of different thickness
CasesT_MD1 intact shell; T_MD2 bare man door; T_MD3 man door with 65 mm door plate and frame; T_V90 two opposite framed ventilation openings, 90° wind
ElementsSHELL181 shells with a mesh refined around each opening; MPC184 rigid beams to a top reference node
MaterialBilinear isotropic steel, E 210 GPa, ν 0.3, yield 355 MPa, 470 MPa at 0.15 plastic strain
LoadsAt the top node: H = 1.255 MN, V = 6.5 H = 8.158 MN, M = 110 m × H = 138.05 MN·m (paper Figure 6), all scaled by one load factor λ
SupportsFixed base
AnalysisLinear buckling → modes scaled to 18.8 mm as imperfections → GMNIA with arc-length to beyond the peak
SoftwareAnsys Workbench and Ansys Mechanical APDL; model files and run script included, so it runs in your own Ansys

Results against the paper

CasePeak λ, paperPeak λ, AnsysDifference
Intact shell (T_MD1)1.5301.463−4.4 %
Bare man door (T_MD2)1.1821.197+1.3 %
65 mm door plate + frame (T_MD3)1.5321.483−3.2 %
Two framed vents, 90° wind (T_V90)1.4761.435−2.8 %
Man door equilibrium paths in Ansys vs Gantes et al. 2024 Figure 7
Man-door equilibrium paths against Figure 7 of the paper: the bare door lowers the peak, the 65 mm plate and frame bring it back to the intact level.
Framed ventilation openings under 90 degree wind in Ansys vs Gantes et al. 2024 Figure 11
Two framed ventilation openings with the wind along the openings, against Figure 11 of the paper.

What the comparison shows

All four peak load factors are within 4.4 % of the paper. The bare man door lowers the peak by 18.2 % in Ansys (22.8 % in the paper), and the 65 mm door plate with its frame brings the tower back to the strength of the intact shell in both. The buckle forms at the door elevation for the bare opening and moves into the shell above the door once the opening is reinforced, the same pattern as in the paper.

Pre-processing in Ansys

Shell geometry and thickness sections of the wind turbine tower with man door and vents in Ansys
Shell geometry and thickness by section for the intact tower, the framed man door and the two framed vents.
Ansys SHELL181 mesh of the wind turbine tower refined around the man door and ventilation opening
SHELL181 mesh, refined around the man door and the ventilation openings.
Loads and supports of the wind turbine tower shell model in Ansys Mechanical APDL
Fixed base and rigid top; the design actions act at the top reference node.
Linear buckling modes used as imperfections for the GMNIA of a wind turbine tower in Ansys
Linear buckling modes of the bare-door tower, scaled to 18.8 mm and added to the geometry before the nonlinear analysis.

Post-processing: how the towers fail

von Mises after the peak load: intact shell, bare man door and framed man door in Ansys
von Mises stress after the peak load for the intact shell, the bare man door and the framed man door.
Equivalent plastic strain at the bare and framed man door after the peak load in Ansys
Equivalent plastic strain: plasticity concentrates at the door edges of the bare opening; with the plate and frame it moves into the shell above.
von Mises after the peak in the tower with two framed ventilation openings in Ansys
Tower with two framed ventilation openings: the buckle forms near the top on the compression side.
Unedited Ansys Mechanical APDL von Mises contour of the bare man door tower after the peak load
Unedited Ansys Mechanical APDL result plot (bare man door, after the peak), exactly as exported by the solver.

Course Content

The results report (PDF) included with the package covers:

  1. Wind turbine tower buckling near man door and ventilation openings: the four benchmark cases and the equilibrium-path comparison with the paper
  2. Geometry and pre-processing in Ansys: SHELL181 shell model, rigid top, fixed base, S355 material and the design actions H, V = 6.5 H and M = 110 m × H
  3. Man-door equilibrium paths vs paper Figure 7: intact shell, bare man door and 65 mm door plate with frame
  4. Framed ventilation openings under 90° wind vs paper Figure 11
  5. Failure locations, von Mises and plastic strain contours vs paper Figures 8, 9 and 13
  6. Figure set: mesh, loads and supports, buckling-mode imperfections, post-peak contours and the results table

What is in the package

  • Ansys Workbench project (.wbpz) with all four cases
  • APDL input files for each case: mesh, linear buckling, mode-shape imperfection, GMNIA and result extraction
  • One-click Python run script: runs the linear buckling, the imperfection and the GMNIA for every case and writes the equilibrium paths, with no edits needed
  • Results report (PDF): every result side by side with the paper
  • README with contents, loads and how to run

Who it is for

Wind-energy and tower engineers who design door and vent reinforcement, FEA engineers who want a working LBA + GMNIA shell buckling workflow in Ansys with mode imperfections and arc-length control, and students who want to see a published tower buckling study rebuilt and checked against the paper.

Also available in Abaqus: wind turbine tower door opening buckling in Abaqus.

Frequently asked questions

Which paper does this package reproduce? Gantes, Vernardos, Koulatsou and Gul, Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis of Tubular Steel Wind Turbine Towers near Man Door and Ventilation Openings to Optimize Design against Buckling, Vibration 2024, 7, 212-228, doi 10.3390/vibration7010012 (open access). The paper is cited, not bundled.

How close are the results to the paper? Peak load factor, paper / Ansys: intact shell 1.530 / 1.463, bare man door 1.182 / 1.197, 65 mm door plate and frame 1.532 / 1.483, two framed vents under 90 degree wind 1.476 / 1.435. All four are within 4.4 %.

Which analyses are included? A linear buckling analysis gives the buckling modes, which are scaled to 18.8 mm and added to the geometry. A geometrically and materially nonlinear analysis with imperfections (GMNIA) with arc-length control then follows each tower past its peak load.

What are the loads? The design actions of the paper (Figure 6) at a rigid top reference node: H = 1.255 MN, V = 6.5 H and M = 110 m x H, all multiplied by one load factor. The base is fixed.

Do I get a Workbench project? Yes. The package holds one archived Ansys Workbench project (.wbpz) with all four cases, the APDL input files for each case and a Python script that runs every case in one click.

What if the package is not what I expected? Write to us. Engineering Downloads refunds clients who are not satisfied with a delivered product.

Need more than the files?

There are two ways we can help. Book a one hour online consultation if you want to talk a problem through with a CAE engineer, using the checkbox in the order box. Order a project if you need a full simulation built for you, delivered to an agreed scope, price and deadline under a written contract.

We work on FEA and CFD for engineers, researchers and companies. Order your project, or message us on WhatsApp for a quick reply.

Course Content

Product files

  • Ansys Workbench project + APDL files + run script + report (complete package)
  • Results report (PDF)

Reviews

No Review Yet
No Review Yet
€129,00
Optional extras

Need a full custom project? See the options below.

17 people watching this product now!

Material Includes

  • Ansys Workbench project (.wbpz) with all four cases
  • APDL input files per case: mesh, linear buckling, imperfection, GMNIA, extraction
  • One-click Python run script
  • Results report (PDF): every result side by side with the paper
  • README

Audience

  • Wind-energy and tower engineers designing door and vent reinforcement
  • FEA engineers learning LBA + GMNIA shell buckling in Ansys
  • MSc and PhD students in shell buckling and steel structures

Related  Products

See more

Want to receive push notifications for all major on-site activities?

✕